This was an impulsive buy as I was looking for a good mascara in brown colour for ages and was delighted by the price offered by salonskincare on this product. The packaging is great, the brush is comfortable to use and the colour looks very nice and more natural ( in my opinion) than black. However, after applying mascara on upper lashes be careful not to look up straight away as it will leave tiny dots on your upper lid. I suppose its because the mascara is so new and thats why so liquid, I always found that slightly dried mascaras are the best to use. The only bad point about this mascara is that it is really hard to remove! I soak the cotton pad in solution, put it on my lid, let it stay for a minute and even after that I have to rub it for a minute..and even then its not completely off! If you are not put off by that, then definately buy as it fans out lashes perfectly, gives nice and volume:)